My 2019 ARC Pledge

Hi all!

So if, like me, you have a problem with ARCs, this post is for you.

Let me explain:

I love ARCs. I really do. I love being given the chance and responsibility from publishers to read books early and provide them with an honest review. It’s not something that any blogger should take lightly, because it’s a very privileged thing we’ve been given. Websites like Netgalley and Edelweiss have made it even easier — for the most part, depending on your location in the world — to receive ARCs. Not to mention if you happen to be part of a blogging / review team, you always have the chance to read and review ARCs.

That being said, I think I need to quit. At least for a little while.

Screen Shot 2018-07-04 at 6.51.19 pm

Now, I fully understand this is entirely my fault, so please don’t come after me in the comments, but I have a tendency to request way too many ARCs — even some I’m not interested in. Why, you may ask?

Because of the hype!

I love when readers and bloggers hype up a book that hasn’t been released it. It’s so good to support authors and books, even before they’re published because that will lead to more sales, but I tend to get swept up in the mania. And I think a lot of other people do too.

When I see someone hyping up a book and then find that same book on Netgalley or Edelweiss, I request it. Then I may or may not be approved for it, but if I am, I am immediately filled with regret. Why did I request this book? I’m not interested in such a novel! Of course I have no one to blame but myself, because my decision has left me with quite a few unread ARCs on my shelf … even months after they’ve actually been published.

And what’s worse, in my opinion, is that my approval for a certain ARC might mean that someone who really wanted to read it, missed out. Sometimes that might be a marginalised teen who shares an aspect of their identity with the main character of an ARC.

Screen Shot 2018-07-04 at 6.51.19 pm

The best example of this was when ARCs of Sandhya Menon’s There’s Something About Sweetie were released on Netgalley (or Edelweiss, I forget which site). A lot of bloggers were requesting this book and being approved for it, which lead to many reviewers and readers of colour — many of whom were fat (as Sweetie from the novel is fat and Indian) — being left out. Now the conversation surrounding the privilege of white reviewers being given ARCs about POC by publishers is best saved for another day — and by someone who has more knowledge and experience than myself — but I felt that this was grievously unfair on the part of readers of colour. And I didn’t want to be that person who took an ARC away from someone who not only really wanted it, but deserved it, when all I had felt for it was mild interest — because of the hype. I can’t remember who said it, but someone I follow on Twitter said it perfectly: “Please, white reviewers, let fat women of colour have this [ARC].”

Which leads me to my next point:


I think, when it comes to ARCs, a lot of reviewers and bloggers get into this terrible mind-frame: they have to have it. At one stage I was like that. I would get so excited over an ARC that I was blinded to the larger issues surrounding the acquisition of ARCs and who is prioritised over who. I remember seeing a lot of conversations on Twitter last year, during BookCon and a number of other book conventions. Two stories particularly stick in my mind: of two older — like in their late 20s/early 30s — women knocking into a teenager in their quest to get an ARC of a book, and other older woman discussing how many ARCs she wanted to get, regardless of whether or not she actually wanted the books. I think we can all agree that’s pretty shitty behaviour.

Screen Shot 2018-07-04 at 6.51.19 pm

A lot of us have a tendency to forget that, at the end of the day, this is an advance reading copy of a book that will be out in a few months anyway. If, like me, you are someone older in the book community, there’s a good chance you can wait those extra few months and purchase the book yourself.

I’m not trying to tell anyone off here, so I apologise if it comes across that way. If you’re interested in a book, you have every right to request it. This is just how I’ve been feeling recently, and, as I hadn’t been requesting as many ARCs during the end of 2018, I’ve actually been feeling a whole lot better. I’ve seen the hype for a book, stopped myself from requesting it, and then, when faced with the decision to spend my actual money on it, have thought long and hard about whether I’m actually interested in the book or if it was just the hype.

Which leads me to my pledge …

Screen Shot 2018-12-29 at 11.40.06 am

I, Laura, solemnly swear to only request an advance reading copy of a novel if I’m actually, 100%, totally interested in it.
I solemnly swear to not be taken in by the hype and to think properly about whether or not I find the ARC in question intriguing.
I solemnly swear to only go on websites like Netgalley and Edelweiss no more than once a month and to instead focus on my ever-expanding backlist of books on my TBR.


Screen Shot 2018-07-04 at 6.51.19 pm

Screen Shot 2018-12-29 at 11.53.08 am

What do you think of my 2019 ARC pledge? Do you have the same problems with ARCs? Do you ever feel left out when you don’t receive an ARC you really wanted? What are your thoughts about ARCs in general? Let me know!

18 thoughts on “My 2019 ARC Pledge

  1. Silvia says:

    This is an excellent post, Laura! I’ve been trying to only request ARCs that I know I will read (I think of it as “books I would preorder anyway”) but I’m still struggling with this, especially since sometimes I become less interested in a book between the time I’ve requested it and the time I’m actually approved for it. It sounds awful, I know! I think whenever I feel like requesting an ARC again I will try to remember that giving it to me might mean a marginalized teen might not get it, because that’s such a great point you made in your post and it’s 100% true.

    Liked by 1 person

    • thebookcorps says:

      Thanks Silvia!! Thats a good way of looking at it: books I would preorder anyway! I’m going to start doing that too! And yes I feel you on requesting an arc and they not being bothered when you actually get approved 😅 Happens to me all the time haha
      Thank you 😘💕

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Kristina Steiner says:

    I don’t have the same issue with ARCs but I did make a pledge not to buy books just because there was hype surrounding them. If I don’t think I’ll like the book based on the plot, I skip it. And I try to find books and authors that haven’t been read by thousands of people.

    Liked by 1 person

    • thebookcorps says:

      This used to be me, so I feel you! I used to buy so many books because of the hype and once I started reading them I’d be like “this is not interesting, why did I buy it?” Thankfully, I live very close to a library and they will buy a book for you, so long as it’s been published within the last 2 years, so I just wait for them to buy it if I get into that hype mood lol.
      Good luck with your pledge!


  3. Kathy @ Books & Munches says:

    ARC’s are such a sensitive subject for a lot of us. I don’t blame people for getting ARC’s, at all. The only thing I struggle with is how I end up feeling being rejected and denied over and over and over again – mostly because I’m an international blogger.
    I feel like publishers don’t really look closely at who they’re approving for ARC’s? Not only rep-wise, but also in general. Sure, a blog might have amazing traffic, but if that person has a feedback ratio of 50% on NetGalley? Shouldn’t they think twice? Or thrice?

    [This is my frustration over yesterday’s denials of my requests and then someone who has a HUGE backlog of ARC’s getting approved for the exact same titles, haha. I was so pissed. :’)]

    In any case, I never request books I’m not genuinely interested in and of which I know I have the time to read and review it in time. I’ve honestly never reviewed an ARC late, at all. I’m proud of that and I’m hoping to stick to that as well. :’)

    Liked by 1 person

    • thebookcorps says:

      It is definitely a sensitive subject on both sides. It’s hard, I’m also an international blogger but being Australian I definitely receive more than other international bloggers so I can’t speak for all, but you’re 100%: a big problem with arc receiving is publishers giving the same (usually American) bloggers arcs over and over again and no one else.

      Oh no!! that can always be really frustrating. I honestly don’t know what publishers look for when they approve arcs. I have a 94% ratio on net galley and I still get declined sometimes.

      I’m glad you review arcs so timely!! My problem is ALL ME lmao! I’m trying to give myself some accountability by posting this blog post, and trying to stop myself from only reading arcs and get back to reading my backlist.


      Liked by 1 person

      • Kathy @ Books & Munches says:

        Hm, true. AU is still “international” but on the subject of ARC’s just that.. little bit less so? I guess?
        I recently read something by someone saying they quit their blog years ago but still keep getting ARC’s even though they stopped reviewing and I was like.. “are you serious..” :’)

        I don’t either! I wish they’d give us less vague criticisms? Like, okay you need to have a following and some traffic but.. what EXACTLY? Because I know for a fact that I have more traffic than some bigger blogs [no boasting here; I simply succeeded at comparing stats with a couple of people] and I still get declined all over the place. :/

        Haha! Honestly, I wish I could do that as well. I review my ARC’s timely, but I also have this feeling I always need at least a couple of ARC’s on my TBR? I have no clue why I feel like that; I just do? It’s weird..

        Liked by 1 person

      • thebookcorps says:

        Yeah Australian bloggers definitely have more privilege than most other international bloggers.

        What?? Someone still receives arcs even though they don’t have a blog or review? So are publishers not even checking this person’s blog? No one thought “hmmm this person hasn’t sent us a review in years, maybe we shouldn’t be sending them anymore arcs?” ughhhhh

        No, I feel you! Sometimes I feel like I need an arc hahah

        Liked by 1 person

      • Kathy @ Books & Munches says:

        Yuup. They don’t check and as far as I gathered, said person even let the publisher(s) [don’t know if it’s one or multiple] know she no longer reviews on any platform anymore and they STILL send her ARC’s. I simply don’t get it. You’d think they’d be more careful since they’re still spending money but apparently not?

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s